Reader Question: Does a Mentor character always have to be right?

What if the Protagonist has to turn away from logic and follow their heart?

A question from Annika:

In your five archetypes that populate almost every movie, does the Mentor always have to be right? If the issue at hand came down to heart versus head and the protagonist should be using their heart more, could being under the influence of a mentor, who approaches things from a head-centered space, actually be working against them? So, basically, can the Mentor and Attractor work against each other?

In answer to your first question, there are no rules in screenwriting, nor with archetypes. They are simply tools to help us develop and understand our stories. So can a Mentor be wrong? Yes.

Re your second question: Can a Mentor and Attractor work against each other? Sure. A perfect example is in The Shawshank Redemption. I consider that to be a Dual Protagonist narrative with Andy and Red each having their own major storyline. Looking at the story through Red’s perspective, here’s how I see the character archetype lineup:

Protagonist — Red
Nemesis — Institutionalization
Attractor — Andy
Mentor — Brooks
Trickster — Freedom (when he gets released from prison)

Brooks (played wonderfully by James Whitmore) represents what I call Negative Wisdom in that he’s a Mentor who shows Red the wrong path. How? By gaining his freedom, then choosing to commit suicide.

Image for post
Image for post

The fact that when Red is released, he goes to work in the same grocery store as Brooks, lives in the same halfway house, and face the same choice Brooks does — find a way to live with freedom or turn against it — spotlights Brooks as Mentor. Indeed, Red is sorely tempted to, at least, commit a crime and get sent back to prison:

And what was that promise?

Right there we see the choice crystallized: Go the route of the Mentor (Brooks) or Attractor (Andy). And Red’s emotional connection to Andy proves stronger than the dark wisdom of Brooks.

Image for post
Image for post

Sometimes in a story, the Protagonist faces a choice: Follow their head or follow their heart. In cases like that, we can use the Mentor and Attractor archetype to physicalize that choice.

Comment Archive

For more Go Into The Story Reader Question articles, go here.

Written by

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store